As far as my understanding goes, no man, woman or child who saw the film My Girl soon after its 1992 release was able to refrain from shedding a tear while watching the accidental death of our girl Vada’s best friend, Thomas J. Thus I took it in stride over ten years later when my longtime penpal Paterson revealed to me that he too had been similarly overwhelmed by emotion during the movie’s fateful scene. It seemed such a given to me that seeing My Girl meant crying with My Girl that I didn’t think twice when sharing Paterson’s admission with our friend Kaitlyn. The only problem was that Paterson had designs on Kaitlyn at the time. He would later inform me that passing along word of his Kleenex moment was not a “bro move.”
The rapper Ja Rule once sang, “When I cry, you cry, we cry…together.” That’s pretty much what I wanted to email Paterson back in the midst of this spat between us, two men in our mid-twenties. But even moreso it’s what I wanted to break through the screen and convey to Vada so that she didn’t feel so alone after losing her best friend and—dare I say—future potential love interest at such a young age. But back when I first met Vada, there was no Ja Rule. And so there were no words. So we just cried.
My Girl was one of those movies that I had to wait and see as a rental back in the seventh grade. It was always tricky roping the dudes you hung around to go see such sentimental tween fluff. Sometimes there was a movie like My Father the Hero that you could sneak past their sissy radar under the guise that you were all just going to check out how hot this Katherine Heigl chick really was. But none of the guys were buying that My Girl might be another chance to catch Macaulay Culkin riffing like the badass that made him an instant hero to us in Home Alone.
The seventh grade boys still weren’t even sure how they felt after being lured into The Good Son, where Macaulay plays a tween sociopath who wants to murder his family. That was some heavy shit. I loved it. Now Macaulay was gearing up for something even heavier—romance. The previews couldn’t hide what was going on here: the Motown that he’d be listening to, the cute glasses that he’d be wearing, the frolicking that he’d be taking part in. If I wanted a taste of that action, I was going to have to take the road less traveled.
So I stayed home (yes, alone) on a Friday night and choked up watching My Girl. Let’s be honest here. This wasn’t the worst set up in the world. There was a reason I enjoyed being by myself while watching it and it wasn’t because I was embarrassed to cry around other guys (trust me). The weekend My Father the Hero came out, I convinced the crew of nerdy dudes I was rolling with at the time to take a week off from street hockey (in sneakers, none of us really knew how to skate) and instead take a walk down to the Riverdale Twin and catch the Saturday matinee.
I had seen the previews for My Father the Hero, a movie about a mouthy teenage girl on vacation with her fool of a French dad. They couldn’t have been more aptly dubbed “coming attractions.” There was an attraction on its way all right, between me and the wisecracking heroine played by a fourteen-year-old Katherine Heigl. Getting to the theaters was the only way I could escalate it to a full-blown crush. Is this something that I wanted my dorky buddies around for? Hells no. But it was a sacrifice that I had to make. Why? Because I was too young to understand that occasionally it is considered socially acceptable to go to the movies by yourself.
With My Girl, there would have to be no such concessions. It was just me, Vada and Thomas J. on VHS. And yes, by the movie’s sad conclusion, I would end up quite moved. Have I mentioned already that I cried? Can I say it a few more times? The movie My Girl starring Anna Chlumsky and Macaulay Culkin brought me to tears. Every time I think of its title, I am overwhelmed by memories of this onslaught of grief that it stirred in me. But in the name of full disclosure, I must also admit that I was not immediately cast under a puppy dog-eyed spell by My Girl’s Vada. She just didn’t dazzle me the same way I was instantly drawn in by Katherine Heigl’s moxie-filled star turn in My Father.
Vada didn’t come across as my type. She was one of those girls who was really into her mood ring. It felt like she constantly talked about it. What color is the mood ring today? How is Vada dealing with her mom still being dead this morning? Maybe a walk down to the pond would brighten things up. Vada was so emotional. I wasn’t sure if things could ever work out between us. I felt like I was going to wind up the sensitive one in the relationship once the love of my life came along. That just wasn’t gonna happen if I fell for Vada and her color coordinated crying all the time.
Now this is where Thomas J. really saved us. It was not that I related so strongly with this spacey but sweet, spectacled boy who was saddled with a laundry list of serious allergies. I was a wiseass who wore my 20/15 vision on my sleeve. What was more important than what the character of Thomas J. was like was who Thomas J. actually was. Thomas J. was Macaulay Culkin. And back in 1992, Macaulay Culkin was me.
Macaulay and I were born just a few days apart from each other. We both started out with bright blond hair. We had a fiercely cutting wit in our arsenal whenever needed it. We each had a dark side. After about the tenth time seeing Home Alone in 1991, I was inspired with an idea for my first novel. It was about the adventures of a twelve-year-old kid who one day wins the lottery. Yes, it was about me. But also, it was about Macaualay.
So when Thomas J. stepped too close to the beehive and met his maker on that sad day by the pond, who was going to step in and be there to comfort poor Vada? In that moment, it all became clear. Maybe there didn’t just have to be one sensitive side to the love of yr life. Maybe Kaitlyn eventually fell for Paterson because she knew they were both suckers for tearjerkers.
Are you there, Vada? It’s me, Billy Hot Chocolate. I just wanted to let you know: when I cry, you cry, we cry…together.